All-Academic First Team
| Student-Athlete Name | School Attended | Graduating Class |
| Ciara Everly | Good Hope | 2023 |
| Grace Hare | York Suburban | 2022 |
| Micheal Hester | Centerville | 2023 |
| Ryan Hilton | Hempfield | 2021 |
| Camden Hurst | Lampeter-Strasburg | 2023 |
| Nolan Gilbert | Good Hope | 2023 |
| Trey Grube | Manheim Central | 2023 |
| Peyton Jaquis | Lancaster Catholic | 2019 |
| Miranda Keller | Bishop McDevitt | 2021 |
| Anya Miller | Linden Hall | 2019 |
| Ryan Parise | Elizabethtown | 2020 |
| Luke Pierson | Elizabethtown | 2021 |
| Sydney Pierson | Elizabethtown | 2019 |
| Lexi Risha | State College | 2019 |
| Elizabeth Staub | Bishop McDevitt | 2020 |
| Alexia Thomas | Bishop McDevitt | 2019 |
| Connor Wright | Greencastle-Antrim | 2023 |
All-Academic Second Team
| Student-Athlete Name | School Attended | Graduating Class |
