All-Academic First Team
| Student-Athlete Name | School Attended | Graduating Class |
| Peyton Bechtold | Big Spring | 2018 |
| Presley Berryhill | New Oxford | 2018 |
| Will Bowen | Lower Dauphin | 2019 |
| Elizabeth Czekaj | State College/td> | 2018 |
| Elijah Eberly | Elizabethtown | 2020 |
| Megan Emlet | Big Spring | 2018 |
| Summer Emlet | Oak Flat Elementary | 2024 |
| Ciara Everly | Good Hope | 2023 |
| Rebecca Franklin | Big Spring | 2020 |
| Abbie Getz | Shallow Brooke IM | 2023 |
| Nolan Gilbert | Good Hope Middle | 2023 |
| Trey Grube | Manheim Central Middle | 2023 |
| Grace Hare | York Suburban Middle | 2022 |
| Alayna Harris | West York | 2020 |
| Michael Hester | Centerville Elementary | 2023 |
| Ryan Hilton | Landisville Middle | 2021 |
| Nicholas Hines | Hershey | 2018 |
| Ryan Hughes | Middletown | 2018 |
| Griffin Jackson | Hershey | 2019 |
| Peyton Jaquis | Lancaster Catholic | 2019 |
| Lilyana Kamarer | Allen Middle | 2022 |
| Reagan Kunkle | West York Middle | 2023 |
| Roderick “Deucie” Lee | Central Dauphin | 2019 |
| Jackson Mascari | Hershey Middle | 2021 |
| Selena Mann | State College | 2019 |
| Anya Miller | Linden Hall | 2019 |
| Tyler Mozeleski | Holy Cross | 2019 |
| Ryan Parise | Elizabethtown | 2020 |
| Luke Pierson | Elizabethtown | 2021 |
| Sydney Pierson | Elizabethtown | 2019 |
| Rachel Reilly | Cedar Cliff | 2018 |
| Lexi Risha | State College | 2019 |
| Ryan Russo | Central Dauphin Middle | 2022 |
| Natalie Sassano | Cedar Cliff | 2019 |
| Meghan Schraeder | Allen Middle | 2022 |
| Daelyn Stabler | New Oxford | 2019 |
| Elizabeth Staub | Bishop McDevitt | 2020 |
| Kyle Wassell | Centerville Elementary | 2023 |
| Grady Wolfe | Hershey Middle | 2023 |
All-Academic Second Team
| Student-Athlete Name | School Attended | Graduating Class |
| Olivia Fasick | Bishop McDevitt | 2019 |
| Samantha Reilly | Allen Middle | 2022 |
| Alexia Thomas | Bishop McDevitt | 2019 |
