All-Academic First Team
| Student-Athlete Name | School Attended | Graduating Class |
| Andrew Adkins | Central Dauphin Middle | 2020 |
| Maya Arora | Good Shepherd School | 2020 |
| Jia Bradford | St. Margaret Mary | 2020 |
| Diamond Bragg | Camp Hill Middle | 2018 |
| Briana Breski | Bishop McDevitt | 2017 |
| Jasmine Chisholm | Harrisburg Catholic | 2019 |
| Brock Geiman | South Western High | 2016 |
| Lauren Gerula | Central Dauphin Middle | 2019 |
| Mason Griffiths | Linglestown Middle | 2019 |
| Essence Hall | Linglestown Middle | 2018 |
| Alayna Harris | West York Middle | 2020 |
| Payton Hauck | Northeastern High | 2015 |
| Tyler Hoagland | Cedar Cliff High | 2015 |
| Bianca Jasper | Middletown | 2017 |
| Kyla Irwin | State College High | 2016 |
| Ashley Johnson | Cumberland Valley High | 2015 |
| Kylie Johnson | St. Margaret Mary | 2020 |
| Matt Jones | Mountain View Elementary | 2021 |
| Cami Karnash | Linglestown Middle | 2019 |
| Addison Kirkpatrick | Cumberland Valley High | 2017 |
| Alec Kulina | St. Joan of Arc | 2019 |
| Roderick “Deucie” Lee | Linglestown Middle | 2019 |
| Alexis Lewis | Holy Redeemer | 2015 |
| Grace Long | Central Dauphin High | 2017 |
| Dominic Matas | Seton (Home School) | 2020 |
| Maximillian Matas | Seton (Home School) | 2018 |
| Katelyn Murawski | Holy Name of Jesus | 2020 |
| Amber Orban | Elizabethtown | 2017 |
| Ryan Parise | Bear Creek School | 2020 |
| Gabrielle Patterson | Central Dauphin East High | 2017 |
| Jacob Perry | Camp Hill Middle | 2020 |
| Lauren Purcell | Bishop McDevitt | 2015 |
| Alyse Rawls | Central Dauphin East | 2017 |
| Jessica Rawls | Central Dauphin East | 2017 |
| Chandler Reeck | Martin Meylin Middle | 2020 |
| Brittany Robinson | Central Dauphin East High | 2015 |
| Jannelle “Honey” Robinson | New Cumberland Middle | 2017 |
| Autumn Royer | Swatara Middle | 2017 |
| Blair Schuyler | Central Dauphin High | 2017 |
| Ben Stubljar | Central Dauphin Middle | 2017 |
| Rachel Sweger | Elizabethtown High | 2016 |
| Blake Thomson | Cedar Crest Middle | 2018 |
| Morgan Thomson | Cedar Crest Middle | 2019 |
| Angela Tonrey | Cumberland Valley High | 2016 |
| Jessica Tonrey | Cumberland Valley High | 2017 |
| Ahmya Woodyard | Harrisburg High | 2017 |
All-Academic Second Team
| Student-Athlete Name | School Attended | Graduating Class |
| Dylan Sweger | Elizabethtown Middle | 2019 |
| Alexia Thomas | Holy Name of Jesus | 2019 |
