All-Academic First Team
| Student-Athlete Name | School Attended | Graduating Class |
| Elliot Blubaugh | Hershey | 2021 |
| Will Bowen | Lower Dauphin | 2019 |
| Margaret “Maggie” Boyle | York Catholic | 2019 |
| Briana Breski | Bishop McDevitt | 2017 |
| Margrett Brown | West Perry | 2019 |
| Meredith Brown | West Perry | 2017 |
| Jack Bucher | Trinity | 2018 |
| Abby Copeland | St. Joseph’s School | 2020 |
| Elizabeth Czekaj | State College | 2018 |
| Elijah Eberly | Elizabethtown | 2020 |
| Megan Emlet | Big Spring | 2018 |
| Jenay Faulkner | Greencastle-Antrim | 2017 |
| Caleb Gibbs | Lower Dauphin | 2021 |
| Aunbrielle Green | Central Dauphin East | 2018 |
| Matthew Halulakos | Central Dauphin Middle | 2022 |
| Alayna Harris | West York Middle | 2020 |
| Mitch Henry | East Pennsboro | 2017 |
| Michael Hester | Centerville Elementary | 2023 |
| Ryan Hilton | Landisville Middle | 2021 |
| Allison Hinish | Cumberland Valley | 2018 |
| Peyton Jaquis | Lancaster Catholic | 2019 |
| Bianca Jasper | Middletown Area High | 2017 |
| Roderick “Deucie” Lee | Central Dauphin | 2019 |
| Larry Locker | Elizabethtown | 2019 |
| Marena Lonardi | Elizabethtown | 2019 |
| Grace Long | Central Dauphin | 2018 |
| Pauliina Malinen | Lower Dauphin | 2018 |
| Selena Mann | State College | 2019 |
| Mariah Martin | Shippensburg Area High | 2018 |
| Maximilian “Max” Matas | Bishop McDevitt | 2018 |
| Anya Miller | Linden Hall | 2019 |
| Noah Myers | Annville-Cleona | 2018 |
| Brok Oldac | Landis Run Intermediate | 2022 |
| Zachary Oldac | Manheim Township | 2020 |
| Amber Orban | Elizabethtown | 2018 |
| Ryan Parise | Elizabethtown | 2020 |
| Ryan Perks | Grays Woods | 2023 |
| Sydney Pierson | Elizabethtown | 2019 |
| Rachael Reilly | Cedar Cliff | 2018 |
| Lexi Risha | State College | 2019 |
| Jannelle “Honey” Robinson | Cedar Cliff | 2018 |
| Autumn Royer | Central Dauphin East | 2018 |
| Kathryn Sansom | St. Theresa | 2024 |
| Natalie Sassano | Cedar Cliff | 2019 |
| Emma Saxton | Central York | 2017 |
| Jarrad Smith Jr. | Susquehanna Twp. | 2020 |
| Gracie Stauffer | West Perry | 2017 |
| Faith St.Clair | Central Dauphin | 2018 |
| Karson Swogger | Bellwood-Antis | 2017 |
| Haley Thomas | Bishop McCort | 2017 |
| Morgan Thomson | Cedar Crest | 2019 |
| Nikson Valencik | Central York | 2018 |
| Emily Ward | Trinity | 2019 |
| Kyle Wassell | Centerville Elementary | 2023 |
| Ahmya Woodyard | Sci-Tech Harrisburg | 2018 |
All-Academic Second Team
| Student-Athlete Name | School Attended | Graduating Class |
| Ben Drury | Good Hope Middle | 2021 |
| Lauren Mills | Lancaster Catholic | 2018 |
| Kara Newell | Shippensburg | 2018 |
| Sheridan Reid | Camp Hill | 2019 |
| Alexia Thomas | Bishop McDevitt | 2019 |
