All-Academic First Team
| Student-Athlete Name | School Attended | Graduating Class |
| Andrew Adkins | Central Dauphin Middle | 2020 |
| Will Bowen | Lower Dauphin Middle | 2019 |
| Briana Breski | BIshop McDevitt | 2017 |
| Elizabeth Czekaj | State College Area High | 2018 |
| Elijah Eberly | Elizabethtown Area Middle | 2020 |
| Jenay N. Faulkner | Greencastle-Antrim High | 2017 |
| Andrew Hahn | Hershey Middle | 2020 |
| Essence Hall | Central Dauphin High | 2018 |
| Luke Hamilton | Hershey Middle | 2020 |
| Bianca Jasper | Middletown Area High | 2017 |
| Matthew Jones | Linglestown Middle | 2021 |
| Paige Kubalak | Penns Valley Jr. High | 2019 |
| Alec Kulina | Saint Joan of Arc School | 2019 |
| Roderick “Deucie” Lee | Linglestown Middle | 2019 |
| Grace Long | Central Dauphin High | 2017 |
| Dominic Matas | Saint Joan of Arc School | 2020 |
| Max Matas | Bishop McDevitt | 2018 |
| Olivia Matto | Manheim Township High | 2018 |
| Donovin Medina | Swatara Middle | 2019 |
| Noah Myers | Annville-Cleona High | 2018 |
| Amber Orban | Elizabethtown Area High | 2018 |
| Ryan Parise | Elizabethtown Area Middle | 2020 |
| Gabriel Patterson | Central Dauphin East High | 2017 |
| Chandler Reeck | Martin Meylin Middle | 2020 |
| Autumn Royer | Central Dauphin East | 2018 |
| Rance Russo | Central Dauphin Middle | 2020 |
| Emma Saxton | Central York High | 2017 |
| Amelia Siders | East Pennsboro Middle | 2021 |
| Benjamin Stubljar | Central Dauphin Middle | 2019 |
| Dylan Sweger | Elizabethtown Area Middle | 2019 |
| Rachel Sweger | Elizabethtown Area High | 2016 |
| Jess Tonrey | Cumberland Valley High | 2017 |
| Nikson Valencik | Central York High | 2018 |
| Emily Ward | St. Joseph School | 2019 |
All-Academic Second Team
| Student-Athlete Name | School Attended | Graduating Class |
| Mason Griffiths | Linglestown Middle | 2019 |
| Alexia Thomas | Holy Name of Jesus | 2019 |
| Jacob Wilson | Hershey High | 2018 |
